NEW YORK
Yoko Ono is suing the producers of a movie that challenges the concept of
Darwinian evolution, saying they used the song "Imagine" without her permission
and led the blogosphere to accuse her of "selling out."
In a lawsuit filed in federal court in Manhattan, Ono accuses the producers
of "Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed" of suggesting to viewers that those who
guard John Lennon's legacy somehow authorized or sponsored the film.
The producers of the film, which features Ben Stein challenging Darwinian
theories that prevail in academic circles and suggesting that life could have
emerged through intelligent design, said they used only "a very small portion of
the song."
"Based on the fair use doctrine, news commentators and film documentarians
regularly use material in the same way we do," Premise Media said in a
statement. "Unbiased viewers of the film will see that the 'Imagine' clip was
used as part of a social commentary in the exercise of free speech and freedom
of inquiry."
Ono's lawsuit claims the producers did not ask for permission either because
they knew they couldn't get it or because they did not want to pay for the
rights. It objects to the way "Imagine" is listed in the film's credits, saying
it suggested to members of the news media and others that the song's use had
been approved.
"Internet 'bloggers' immediately began accusing Mrs. Lennon of 'selling out'
by licensing the song to defendants," says the complaint, filed this week.
The lawsuit calls "Imagine" Lennon's signature song, saying it "has become
closely associated with and is synonymous with John Lennon."
The complaint, which also names other firms involved with the movie, asks the
court to stop the filmmakers from distributing, selling and promoting the movie,
and it seeks financial damages. It was filed on behalf of Ono, Lennon's sons
Sean and Julian, and EMI Blackwood Music Inc.
"Expelled" earned the No. 10 spot at the box office this weekend, bringing in
nearly $3 million in its first weekend in wide release. Stein, an actor, quiz
show host and former speech writer for Presidents Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford,
has been visiting some state capitals to screen the movie for lawmakers.
Copyright 2008 Associated Press