FORT HOOD Texas
A military jury must soon decide whether an Army sergeant committed murder or
followed the rules of engagement when he shot an unarmed insurgent in an Iraqi
village overrun by al-Qaida forces.
The seven-member jury at Sgt. Leonardo Trevino's court-martial was to start
deliberating Thursday after closing arguments by military prosecutors and
defense attorneys.
In testimony that lasted more than three hours, Trevino said Wednesday that
he was innocent of premeditated murder and other charges stemming from the June
killing after a firefight in Muqdadiyah, Iraq.
Trevino testified that after following a trail of blood into a house, he
thought the severely wounded insurgent was a threat because the flailing man
might have been trying to trigger an explosive. After being shot about two dozen
times, the man had fled to one house, jumped off its roof and then scaled a wall
to get to the other house, Trevino said, leading him to wonder if the Iraqi was
leading the soldiers there to sabotage them.
He said that during the chaotic scene, someone yelled that the Iraqi had or
was reaching for a gun, so Trevino shot him. He then asked where the Iraqi's gun
was, and one soldier pulled out a weapon and placed it on the floor, he said.
But Trevino testified that he was disappointed in the implication that they had
to cover up something, so he returned the pistol.
He testified that after a medic arrived and said the insurgent was about to
die, the sergeant scoffed at the medic's suggestion of suffocating the man. He
then left the house to give a report to his superior.
When Trevino returned, he said, he saw the insurgent's arm jerk, then fired
his gun a second time as a reaction without aiming or looking at the man.
Trevino, a 1st Cavalry Division soldier from San Antonio, could face life in
prison if convicted of premeditated murder, attempted murder, obstruction of
justice and solicitation to commit murder.
Asked by his attorney whether he committed those crimes, Trevino said, "No, I
did not."
Trevino acknowledged that the insurgent did not have a pistol, but he said he
wasn't worried when questioned by Army investigators "because all those shots
were legit."
Under cross-examination, Trevino said he saw that the insurgent's arm was
broken, that he had gunshot wounds and that he did not feel the man was a threat
after the medic arrived. He also said several U.S. and Iraqi soldiers were
walking around the room, and he pointed out that explosives did not have to be
in the room to be detonated.
Trevino acknowledged that he told two soldiers in the room that "I don't want
this to come back on you," but said he meant he did not want them to have the
responsibility of guarding a dangerous insurgent and the possibility of having
to shoot him.
A key prosecution witness, Pvt. Tristan Miller, testified earlier that
Trevino said those words before shooting the insurgent in the abdomen, then
directed another soldier to drop a gun by the man and invented the story that
the Iraqi was armed.
Miller also testified that he had kicked a pillow off the insurgent's arm and
saw that he was unarmed and not a threat.
An Army investigator testified Wednesday that in three long interviews with
Miller, the soldier never told him or wrote in his statements that he checked to
see if the insurgent had a weapon.
"We needed to know what kind of threat level they were under by the insurgent
in that room," Mikey Nogle, a special agent for the Army's Criminal
Investigative Division, told the military jury.
The medic, Spc. John Torres, was acquitted in March of attempted premeditated
murder and dereliction of duty for failing to provide aid.
Copyright 2008 Associated Press